Magic, Miracles, and Skepticism

I’ll believe it when I see it.

It seems like the pinnacle of skepticism to set such a requirement, but what happens when we think we see something that we didn’t really see?  There are books about the neurology behind our tendency to believe what we see, but it’s rare to come across the idea in books accessible to young people.

I was delighted to discover a picture book that addressed it on a level I could share with my preschool-age daughter.  In Anton Can Do Magic by Ole Konnecke, we watch as Anton is inspired by a poster of “The Great Sorcar.”  He dons a hat–that is too big–and sets out to do some magic.  When Anton tries to make something disappear, his too-large hat slips over his eyes at just the right moment so that it seems his magic worked.  Readers know the truth, however, which lends kid-appeal to the story.  My four-year-old was able to discern what happened easily, and I think I’ll revisit the book in a couple of years to have a more substantive conversation about how we might need to dig deeper beyond simply what we see.  Read more about Anton Can Do Magic in this review at Kirkus or see some of the illusrations at 7 imp.

The Probability of Miracles by Wendy Wunder delves into belief vs. skepticism for teens (and adults who read teen fiction). In this story Cam–committed skeptic–is terminally ill.  When her doctor tells her there is nothing left he can do for her, Cam’s mother starts looking for a miracle to save her daughter.  Once they exhaust the possibilities offered by non-traditional medicine, they decide to take even more drastic measures.  Cam reluctantly agrees to relocate to a small town in Maine where mysterious things have been said to happen.  She is too busy crossing items off her version of a bucket list to spend much time analyzing the strange things that happen in Promise, Maine.  Readers can interpret everything that happens with the eyes of a believer or those of a skeptic, and I imagine both sides will ardently argue their view before giving in–hopefully realizing that it is the inability to convince each other of what we don’t want to see that is at the heart of the novel.  How ever you read the book, have tissues handy.

I have yet to read The Believing Brain, but it’s definitely been bumped up on my to-read list. :)

See more posts about science, religion, and secular family life on my Secular Thursday page.

Disclosure: Amazon Links are affiliate links.

Author: Mindy R

I'm a librarian, writer, book reviewer, etc.

2 thoughts on “Magic, Miracles, and Skepticism”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: